Summarize this article with AI

One might have bone grafting mentioned in it and the other might not. It’s entirely natural to wonder which of the two you should go with.

Implant dentistry often has more than one valid answer. Two dentists looking at the same scan could well come to different conclusions based on their own training, the implant systems they use and their own individual preference in terms of how cautious they are with the bone and gums. A difference in plans doesn’t necessarily mean one is wrong.

Rather than just asking which option is the cheapest or the quickest, ask why each dentist made the choice they did. Clear reasons are a good thing. Vague answers or an unwillingness to explain are things to be aware of. A second opinion also gives you the opportunity to hear the same information set out in a different way and that often helps it to make sense.

Getting a second opinion on same day dental implants is a perfectly reasonable thing to do and most dentists will understand why a patient would want to do that. This guide looks at the various bits of a treatment plan that are worth reading in parallel.

Start With the Diagnosis Behind Each Plan

A treatment plan is only as good as the data that went into it. Before you start comparing implant numbers or materials you need to know what each dentist actually looked at. Some useful questions to ask would be:

  • Was a 3D CBCT scan done or just a plain X-ray? A CBCT will show you the bone height, bone width and the adjacent structures (nerves, sinuses etc).
  • Did the dentist check your gums for active disease (which would usually need treating first)?
  • Has your bite been assessed (for signs of grinding and clenching)?
  • Did your full medical history and medications get looked at in detail?

If one was based on a full 3D scan and the other on a single X-ray then the two aren’t really comparable at all. It would be fairer to share one scan between the two dentists. This matters even more with same day dental implants, where the whole plan depends on how well the bone can hold an implant on the day of surgery.

Implants: How Many, Where and Which System

For one missing tooth the plans are going to be pretty much the same. The differences start to emerge when you’re looking at multiple missing teeth or a full arch. One dentist may opt to support a full arch of upper teeth on four implants, another may prefer five or six. Neither of those options is in any way wrong per se; it’s just a matter of the individual case and the specific circumstances. You’ve got bone volume, you’ve got bite forces, you’ve got the way the load is going to be distributed. The position of the implant is also important as in some cases you can position the implant to avoid the sinus or the nerve which in turn may mean you don’t need to do any grafting at all.

Ask whether any bone grafting or sinus lift is planned and why it is or is not required. It’s also worth asking which implant brand each clinic uses. The more established the system the better the chance of having the parts available in many countries (if you ever do decide to leave the UAE one day and need a crown replaced or a screw tightened in another country).

What “Same Day” Actually Means in Each Plan

Clinics describe the treatment in all sorts of ways. You’ll see it referred to as same day implants, teeth in a day or one day dental implants and the terminology doesn’t always mean the same thing. Some of the plans will have the implant placed and a temporary tooth in place in the same visit. Others will have the implant placed on day one and the teeth added a few days later.

The key issue is whether the teeth on the day are a firm commitment or a target. Same day loading is contingent upon the implant’s ability to hold in the bone at the time of surgery and no dentist can be certain of that in advance. A good plan will have contingency arrangements in place in the event that that level of stability is not achieved (e.g. a removable temporary to be worn while the implant heals). If the plan makes no mention of this at all then it’s worth asking for clarification.

Temporary Teeth and Final Teeth

Every plan for same day implants involves two sets of teeth. The first is a temporary tooth/bridge (typically made from a lighter form of acrylic) which is worn whilst the implants are osseointegrating (fusing with the bone) over the course of a few months. Your final set of teeth comes second. When you’re comparing plans, check:

  • Whether both the temporary and final teeth are included
  • What the final teeth will be made of, such as zirconia, porcelain or acrylic on a metal framework
  • How many visits are needed between surgery and the final fit
  • Whether a full-arch bridge is fixed or removable, and how you will clean under it

Material has an effect on the look, the strength and the repairability so you need to ask each dentist why they’ve chosen that particular material for your case. You also need to ask how long you’ll be wearing the temporary teeth and whether they can be repaired if they do chip.

Fees, Inclusions and Aftercare

Comparing the total figures alone can be very misleading as the two quotes may be covering very different things. Always ask for a written breakdown and make sure it includes consultations, scans, extractions, grafting, temporary teeth, final teeth and follow ups. If you have UAE health insurance then ask each clinic which (if any) of the above they will accept as being covered by your policy.

Aftercare absolutely deserves the same consideration. How often will you be seen in the first year? Is a night guard included in the plan if you’re a grinder? What if the implant fails to integrate with the bone (this can happen on occasion even with a very careful procedure)? A clear answer to that final point tells you a great deal about how the clinic will deal with the unforeseen.

Who Will Carry Out the Treatment

Find out who’s going to be placing the implants and who’s going to be making and fitting the teeth. In some clinics it will be the same dentist; in others the work will be shared out between a team. Either arrangement can be quite good as long as you know who is doing what.

Dentists in Dubai must be licensed by the appropriate health authority and the title they use must be the one that is on their licence. It’s a perfectly reasonable question to ask how often they do same day placements.

Preparing for Your Second Opinion Visit

A little preparation makes the second visit far more productive. Bring along:

  • Copies of any scans and X-rays you already have
  • The written treatment plan from your first consultation
  • A list of your medications and any health conditions
  • Questions or concerns that came up after the first visit

Ask both dentists the same fundamental questions so that the answers are as comparable as possible. Taking notes or having a relative with you will help you to remember the details when you get back to your own home. Take the time you need to make your decision as this is a long term commitment and a few extra days of thought is absolutely fine.

Conclusion

A second opinion gives you a much better view of your own mouth and that in itself is worth it. When you’re looking at the various options for same day dental implants, don’t just look at the headlines. Look at the diagnosis, the implants they’re proposing, what you do if the teeth aren’t possible on the day, the materials they’re using and what the aftercare is. Whatever plan you go with you should walk away with a clear understanding of the rationale behind it.

If you already have a plan for your one day dental implants and would like that plan reviewed then the dentists at Magnum Dental Clinic can have a look at your scans and go through the options with you.

Contact Us

If you would like your case assessed in person, our JLT clinic is easy to reach.

Magnum Dental Clinic – JLT

Address: Shop No. 2, Indigo Tower, Cluster D, Al Thanyah Fifth, Jumeirah Lakes Towers, Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Phone: +971 54 452 2332